Skip to content
Home Insurance Index

Home insurance · New York

Otsego County, NY home insurance cost

Updated · Data as of

Homeowners in Otsego County, New York typically pay $1,000–$1,200 a year for home insurance, according to the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey (2020–2024).

Homeowners here typically report paying

$1,000–$1,200

a year, for home insurance

Band 2 of 7 nationally. U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 (owner-reported; includes flood insurance).

Flood

Homes with flood cover 0.5%–1%

Typical flood policy $1,250–$1,500

FEMA NFIP policies in force, September 2026.

Nonrenewals

Under 0.5% of policies not renewed in 2023 About the same as 2018

U.S. Senate Budget Committee, insurer data 2018–2023.

Home insurance in Otsego County

Homeowners in Otsego County typically report paying $1,000–$1,200 a year for home insurance. That's lower than most of New York, and the second-lowest of the seven bands we map nationally. Fewer than 1 in 20 homeowners here report paying $4,000 or more a year.

Only 0.5%–1% of homes in Otsego carry a federal flood policy. Remember that a home policy alone doesn't cover flood damage. Where people do buy it, a typical flood policy costs $1,250–$1,500 a year.

Nonrenewals are part of the picture too. In 2023, under 0.5% of policies from the insurers in a U.S. Senate Budget Committee study weren't renewed, about the same rate as in 2018.

Costs vary inside the county. Its ZIP codes run from under $1,000 up to $1,200–$1,400, which is why your own number matters more than any average.

These are ranges. The exact figures for Otsego, and exactly where your own policy ranks, open up when you share what you pay.

Otsego County by ZIP code

Map of ZIP codes in Otsego County, colored by band ZIP 13747ZIP 13815ZIP 13326ZIP 13342ZIP 13411ZIP 13418ZIP 13468ZIP 13733ZIP 13751ZIP 13843ZIP 13859ZIP 13849ZIP 13339ZIP 13820ZIP 13355ZIP 13838ZIP 13482ZIP 13796ZIP 13825ZIP 13775ZIP 13317ZIP 13834ZIP 12043ZIP 13810ZIP 12474ZIP 13460ZIP 13809ZIP 13757ZIP 13740ZIP 13314ZIP 13780ZIP 13846ZIP 13861ZIP 13450ZIP 13459ZIP 13333ZIP 13335ZIP 13337ZIP 13348ZIP 13364ZIP 13320ZIP 13313ZIP 13839ZIP 13842ZIP 13860ZIP 13475ZIP 13480ZIP 13488ZIP 13739ZIP 13750ZIP 13491ZIP 13753ZIP 13776ZIP 13807ZIP 12155ZIP 12175ZIP 12064ZIP 12093ZIP 13457ZIP 13806ZIP 12036ZIP 13318ZIP 13439ZIP 13788ZIP 12197ZIP 12167ZIP 12149ZIP 13485ZIP 13361ZIP 13315ZIP 13786ZIP 13808ZIP 13415ZIP 12116
What homeowners report paying a year (median)
  1. Under $1,000
  2. $1,000–$1,200
  3. $1,200–$1,400
  4. $1,400–$1,700
  5. $1,700–$2,100
  6. $2,100–$2,800
  7. $2,800 or more
  8. Not enough data

U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 (owner-reported; includes flood insurance).

What this page doesn't show

The exact typical cost for Otsego, each ZIP's own figures, and where you rank among homeowners in your ZIP.

The Census tables behind these ranges are public (see the methodology). What you unlock is our cleaning, the exact figures for your area, the regulator comparison, and figures from neighbors who shared what they pay. It takes about 20 seconds, no account.

What do you pay?

22 ZIP codes

ZIP codes in Otsego County

Each ZIP's band for what homeowners report, and for flood cover. Ranges only. Tap one to see where you stand there.

ZIPs are assigned to the county holding most of their land. Bands: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 (owner-reported; includes flood insurance); flood, FEMA NFIP.

Nearby counties

Questions people ask

How much is home insurance in Otsego County, New York?
Homeowners in Otsego County, New York typically pay $1,000–$1,200 a year for home insurance, according to the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey (2020–2024).
How much is flood insurance in Otsego County, New York?
A typical federal flood insurance (NFIP) policy in Otsego County, New York costs $1,250–$1,500 a year, based on FEMA's policies in force as of September 2026. Private flood policies aren't included. What you pay depends on your home's flood risk, elevation and coverage.
How many homes in Otsego County, New York have flood insurance?
0.5%–1% of homes in Otsego County, New York carry a federal flood insurance (NFIP) policy, based on FEMA's policies in force as of September 2026 and Census housing counts. That's lower than New York as a whole. Private flood policies aren't counted.
Does home insurance cover flooding?
No. A standard homeowners policy doesn't cover flood damage. Flood cover is a separate policy, bought from federal flood insurance (NFIP) or a private insurer, and a new NFIP policy usually takes 30 days to take effect, so it can't be bought once a storm is on the way.

Cite this page

Home Insurance Index, What My Neighbors Pay. “Otsego County, NY home insurance cost.” Updated November 19, 2026; data as of October 2026. https://homeinsuranceindex.com/new-york/otsego-county/

Please also name the original source under each figure. How the numbers are built: methodology. Quoting with attribution is welcome; reproducing the data needs consent (Using our data).

See where you stand

What do you pay in Otsego County?

Ranges are all we publish here. Share what you pay for home insurance and see exactly where you rank among homeowners in your ZIP. Three questions, about 20 seconds, no account.

Published by What My Neighbors Pay. County figures are published as ranges only. This product uses the Federal Emergency Management Agency's OpenFEMA API, but is not endorsed by FEMA. Methodology